• JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 2473
Monday, 17 June 2013 00:00

The Roots of Muslim Rage? Comfy Counter-Narratives Don’t Address Them!

Written by 

When the Muslim community in America reaches a point of finally talking about the issues of radicalism that face Muslim youth, that’s a sure sign that we’ve progressed. Surely, intolerance and hate are incompatible with Islam and need to be made obsolete. But in my opinion, the Muslim community is not always honest about how to address these issues best. In my view, much of the intolerance and hate we see coming from Muslims in the world today is the product of Salafism and its influence.

At a forum jointly organized by the New American Foundation and the Muslim Public Affairs Council (MPAC) titled Online Radicalization: Myths and Realities, the panelists talked about some problems and some solutions in the Muslim community, but not the root causes of those problems. The overarching theme, instead, offered “counter narratives.”

Some of the radical narratives are: “Islam is not compatible with America and Western values,” “America is at war with Islam,” and as Rashad Hussein, President Obama’s Special Envoy to the Organization of Islamic Council said succinctly, “The disbelievers are oppressing brothers and sisters and your duty is to defend them, if they act, they will be rewarded.”

Peter Neumann offered this: “Challenging this kind of (radical) message rather than shutting down extremist sites is what needs to be done.” Thus, rather than taking seriously the possibility that those narratives may be based on real underlying problems, it’s best to just respond with talking points.

Imam Suhaib Webb and New America Foundation (NAF)’s fellow Rabia Chaudry proposed that that, “Counter radicalism narrative needs to be led by Muslims themselves.”

Of course, I agree! But the solution Neumann and Webb offer is simply more of the same conservative and Salafi interpretations of Islam — the very theology that promotes hate and intolerance of everyone else, including Muslims who are just well … not Muslim enough.

According to Webb, he’s counseled male youths successfully who have proclaimed, “I can’t believe I hated people like this!”

Webb recommends that the theological interpretations that gave birth to intolerance are precisely what is needed to counter the radical narratives, because they have “street cred.” If being hateful defines credibility then we are in for a very long haul.

Webb proclaims that, “Not all salafis are jihadists.” True, but they share the same roots. Has it occurred to Webb, Chaudry and all of the conservative Muslims out there that it is precisely this interpretation of Islam that is the bedrock from which hate, intolerance and exclusivity are derived?

Moving even further away from a solution, CAIR-Los Angeles sponsored a series of talks with award-winning journalist Trevor Aaronson titled “Understanding the Terror Factory – a speaking tour on FBI entrapment of Muslims.” This title is enough to make me cringe.

Is there entrapment by the FBI and local police forces? Absolutely! But please, let’s not blame entrapment methods. The fact that our youth are even tempted at committing the crimes that would lead to their entrapment should have been the focus of the discussion. CAIR and many others in the Muslim community are avoiding the root causes and many on the political Left are just too happy to help Muslims play the victim game.

You are not doing our community and America a service by playing this game. We have to get to the root causes of this anger and violence and destruction.

Instead of offering more Salafi theology as a solution and blaming FBI entrapment, institutions like CAIR and MPAC should be asking why it is that some Muslim kids are led to these terrible paths? Why is it so easy for them? What fuels their worldview and makes it okay inside their heads to even begin a trek in such a horrible direction?

The answer most are unwilling to face up to is simple: when you teach kids that Islam is the superior religion, that our Islamic values are incompatible with that of Western and American values, and that everyone else are kufar, (unbelievers therefore unequal), this interpretation of Islam is exactly the seed from which hate and intolerance, and potential radicalism, takes root and spreads.

I urge Muslims who preach, teach, or advocate this theology to tell me: How are you any different than the radical Israeli settlers who believe that they have the God-given right to discriminate, hate and kill Palestinians? The answer is that you are not different. You are the same.

It is your hateful and intolerant theology that has sowed mayhem in this world.


By Ani Zonneveld, Aslan Media Columnist
*Photo Credit: Robert Reed Daly
Read 9344 times

Add comment

We only welcome and encourage constructive and respectful comments. Please avoid slurs, hate speech, general abuse against other participants, or any incitement of violence.
We reserve the right to delete your comments and block your participation with continued abuse.

Security code


+2 # Abdulmalik Freeman 2013-06-19 02:38
This crypto-imperial ism practiced in and by the various Muslim communities must be repudiated. There is no difference between the search for purity among the youth infected by the teachings of the Salafis and those of the members of the Ketsumeidan Jiken (Blood Pledge Corp) in Japan at the start of World War II. They believed that society should be purified in the name of the Emperor (God) and this could best be accomplished by removing the will of individuals to stand in their way through selective assassination.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
+1 # yajsingh 2013-06-19 12:12
"intolerance and hate are incompatible with Islam" statement is possibly a figment of authors imagination as reality is quite opposite.
Islam from its progeny until date has been cause of incessant destruction, violence & intolerence. Pick any muslim majority country in this age (21st century) and its full of discrimination & hate for minorities, gay, Jews, Hindus & America.
The so called religion of peace is the root cause for violence and its time to acknowledge and address this once & for all.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
0 # Ani Zonneveld 2013-06-19 21:11
[quote name="yajsingh" ]"intolerance and hate are incompatible with Islam" statement is possibly a figment of authors imagination as reality is quite opposite."

yajsingh, siding with radicals are you?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
+1 # yajsingh 2013-06-20 20:03
I'd rather liked to be called a radical or a islamophobic than not call spade a spade. If Islam is peace - show me by action "ye muslim umma" not by argument. History is where is go look for answers contemporary or otherwise; and sadly it ain't forgiving this 'religion of peace".
Be brave, bold to take this animal of peace head-on than lace it with romantic 2 cents.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
0 # Steven Dawson 2013-06-20 00:11
If hatered was eliminated throughout Islam tomorrow how would we ever know, by what sign ? ?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
0 # Ani Zonneveld 2013-06-20 00:44
We Muslims will be the first to know and we'll let you in on it! ;-)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
+1 # Steven Dawson 2013-06-20 11:30
:zzz Lulabys are soothing but I'll keep my eyes open just the same :-?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote